diff --git a/database/migrations/2026_01_14_221937_convert_stock_egg_uuids.php b/database/migrations/2026_01_14_221937_convert_stock_egg_uuids.php
index fb51a8b31..b1c426d1f 100644
--- a/database/migrations/2026_01_14_221937_convert_stock_egg_uuids.php
+++ b/database/migrations/2026_01_14_221937_convert_stock_egg_uuids.php
@@ -8,29 +8,35 @@ return new class extends Migration
     {
         $mappings = [
             // Forge Minecraft
-            'ed072427-f209-4603-875c-f540c6dd5a65' => [
-                'new_uuid' => 'd6018085-eecc-42bf-bf8c-51ea45a69ace',
+            'd6018085-eecc-42bf-bf8c-51ea45a69ace' => [
+                'new_uuid' => 'ed072427-f209-4603-875c-f540c6dd5a65',
                 'new_update_url' => 'https://raw.githubusercontent.com/pelican-eggs/minecraft/refs/heads/main/java/forge/egg-forge-minecraft.yaml',
             ],
 
             // Paper
-            '5da37ef6-58da-4169-90a6-e683e1721247' => [
-                'new_uuid' => '150956be-4164-4086-9057-631ae95505e9',
+            '150956be-4164-4086-9057-631ae95505e9' => [
+                'new_uuid' => '5da37ef6-58da-4169-90a6-e683e1721247',
                 'new_update_url' => 'https://raw.githubusercontent.com/pelican-eggs/minecraft/refs/heads/main/java/paper/egg-paper.yaml',
             ],
 
             // Garrys Mod
-            '60ef81d4-30a2-4d98-ab64-f59c69e2f915' => [
-                'new_uuid' => 'c0b2f96a-f753-4d82-a73e-6e5be2bbadd5',
+            'c0b2f96a-f753-4d82-a73e-6e5be2bbadd5' => [
+                'new_uuid' => '60ef81d4-30a2-4d98-ab64-f59c69e2f915',
                 'new_update_url' => 'https://raw.githubusercontent.com/pelican-eggs/games-steamcmd/refs/heads/main/gmod/egg-garrys-mod.yaml',
             ],
         ];
 
         foreach ($mappings as $oldUuid => $newData) {
-            DB::table('eggs')->where('uuid', $oldUuid)->update([
-                'uuid' => $newData['new_uuid'],
-                'update_url' => $newData['new_update_url'],
-            ]);
+            if (DB::table('eggs')->where('uuid', $newData['new_uuid'])->exists()) {
+                DB::table('eggs')->where('uuid', $newData['new_uuid'])->update([
+                    'update_url' => $newData['new_update_url'],
+                ]);
+            } else {
+                DB::table('eggs')->where('uuid', $oldUuid)->update([
+                    'uuid' => $newData['new_uuid'],
+                    'update_url' => $newData['new_update_url'],
+                ]);
+            }
         }
     }