starred/ProxmoxVE
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/community-scripts/ProxmoxVE.git synced 2026-02-05 00:29:55 +03:00
Code Issues 11 Packages Projects Releases 10 Wiki Activity

Phase 8: Review & Validation - Comprehensive Quality Assurance #2281

New Issue
Closed
opened 2026-02-05 04:23:05 +03:00 by OVERLORD · 1 comment
OVERLORD commented 2026-02-05 04:23:05 +03:00
Owner
Copy Link

Originally created by @cgoss on GitHub (Jan 4, 2026).

Phase 8: Review & Validation

Status

⏳ PENDING - Awaiting completion of previous phases

Objective

Conduct comprehensive review and validation of the entire LLM Context System to ensure accuracy, consistency, completeness, and usability for both human contributors and AI/LLM agents.

Tasks

Task 1: Consistency Review

  • Check consistent terminology across all documentation
  • Verify format consistency (headers, code blocks, tables)
  • Ensure consistent use of bold/italic/markdown
  • Review consistent use of examples and templates
  • Check consistent navigation patterns

Task 2: Accuracy Validation

  • Verify all script names and paths are correct
  • Validate port information matches actual scripts
  • Check that environment variables are accurate
  • Verify whiptail prompt translations are correct
  • Test non-interactive mode examples
  • Validate resource recommendations

Task 3: Completeness Check

  • Ensure all 408 scripts have context files
  • Verify all 26 category files are populated
  • Check that all execution modes are documented
  • Verify all script creation guides are complete
  • Ensure all automation scripts are documented
  • Check that all cross-references work

Task 4: Usability Testing

Test navigation from multiple starting points:

  • From index.md, can AI find any script?
  • From category file, can AI find specific scripts?
  • From execution guide, can AI understand how to execute?
  • From script context, can AI understand dependencies?

Test with example queries:

  • "Find a media server script" → Should navigate to Media category
  • "How do I execute docker.sh non-interactively?" → Should find execution guide
  • "Create a new database service script" → Should find script creation guides
  • "What ports does jellyfin use?" → Should find jellyfin context file

Task 5: Non-Interactive Mode Validation

  • Test default mode execution examples
  • Test advanced mode execution examples
  • Verify storage selection handling
  • Test prompt translation accuracy
  • Validate whiptail menu translations
  • Test error handling documentation

Task 6: Automation Validation

  • Test generate-context.sh on sample scripts
  • Test update-index.sh with new scripts
  • Test scan-new-scripts.sh detection
  • Verify automation script documentation
  • Test automation script error handling

Task 7: Quick Reference Cards

Create quick reference cards for:

  • Non-Interactive Execution - 1-page guide with common patterns
  • Script Creation - 1-page checklist for new scripts
  • Category Navigation - 1-page category reference
  • Common Issues - 1-page troubleshooting guide
  • Storage Selection - 1-page storage handling guide

Task 8: Cross-Reference Audit

  • Verify all links work (no broken links)
  • Check that all references have targets
  • Ensure circular references are intentional and helpful
  • Verify that scripts reference correct documentation
  • Check that categories reference correct scripts

Task 9: Documentation Completeness

Review each major documentation file:

  • .llm-context/README.md - Complete and accurate?
  • .llm-context/index.md - All navigation methods work?
  • Execution docs - All scenarios covered?
  • Script creation guides - All steps clear?
  • Category files - All information present?
  • Script context files - All details accurate?
  • Automation docs - All scripts documented?

Task 10: Integration Review

  • AGENTS.md properly references context system?
  • README.md includes context system?
  • Templates updated correctly?
  • Contributing guidelines accurate?
  • CLI help text updated?
  • All cross-references work?

Validation Checklist

Accuracy

  • All script names match actual scripts
  • All ports are correct
  • All paths are accurate
  • All environment variables documented
  • All examples tested

Consistency

  • Terminology consistent
  • Formatting consistent
  • Structure consistent
  • Navigation patterns consistent

Completeness

  • All 408 scripts have context
  • All 26 categories populated
  • All guides complete
  • All automation scripts documented

Usability

  • Easy to find information
  • Clear instructions
  • Working examples
  • Helpful cross-references

Integration

  • All documentation linked
  • Templates updated
  • Contributing guidelines accurate
  • CLI help updated

Expected Outcomes

  1. High-Quality Documentation

    • Accurate, consistent, complete
    • Easy to navigate
    • Helpful examples

  2. Tested System

    • Non-interactive mode validated
    • Navigation tested
    • Automation scripts tested

  3. Quick References

    • 1-page reference cards
    • Quick start guides
    • Common patterns

  4. Final Integration

    • All documentation linked
    • Templates updated
    • Contributing guidelines accurate

Estimated Time

4-6 hours

Dependencies

  • Phase 1-7 must be complete
  • All context files generated
  • All category files populated
  • All integration tasks complete

Related Issues

  • #10521 - AI Context Enhancement - Overall Plan
  • #10522 - Phase 4: Category Files
  • #10523 - Phase 5: Script Context Files
  • #10524 - Phase 7: Integration & Updates

Resources

  • All LLM Context System documentation
  • Automation scripts for testing
  • Quick reference card templates
  • Validation checklists

Quick Reference Card Templates

Non-Interactive Execution Card

# Non-Interactive Execution Quick Reference

## Default Mode (Simple)
```bash
APP_NAME=example bash ct/example.sh

Advanced Mode (Custom Settings)

APP_NAME=example \
APP_ADVANCED=true \
APP_CPU=4 \
APP_RAM=4096 \
APP_DISK=20 \
APP_STORAGE=local-lvm \
bash ct/example.sh

Storage Selection

Important: Always ask user which storage drive when:

  • User requests advanced settings
  • Script requires storage selection
  • Multiple storage drives available

**Script Creation Card**
```markdown
# Script Creation Quick Reference

## Checklist
- [ ] Research service (use research-methodology.md)
- [ ] Analyze dependencies (use dependency-analysis.md)
- [ ] Plan resources (use resource-planning.md)
- [ ] Select OS (use os-selection.md)
- [ ] Choose pattern (use installation-patterns.md)
- [ ] Use template (use template-guide.md)
- [ ] Test and validate (use testing-validation.md)
- [ ] Follow best practices (use best-practices.md)

Labels: documentation, phase-8, review, qa

Originally created by @cgoss on GitHub (Jan 4, 2026). ## Phase 8: Review & Validation ### Status ⏳ PENDING - Awaiting completion of previous phases ### Objective Conduct comprehensive review and validation of the entire LLM Context System to ensure accuracy, consistency, completeness, and usability for both human contributors and AI/LLM agents. ### Tasks #### Task 1: Consistency Review - [ ] Check consistent terminology across all documentation - [ ] Verify format consistency (headers, code blocks, tables) - [ ] Ensure consistent use of bold/italic/markdown - [ ] Review consistent use of examples and templates - [ ] Check consistent navigation patterns #### Task 2: Accuracy Validation - [ ] Verify all script names and paths are correct - [ ] Validate port information matches actual scripts - [ ] Check that environment variables are accurate - [ ] Verify whiptail prompt translations are correct - [ ] Test non-interactive mode examples - [ ] Validate resource recommendations #### Task 3: Completeness Check - [ ] Ensure all 408 scripts have context files - [ ] Verify all 26 category files are populated - [ ] Check that all execution modes are documented - [ ] Verify all script creation guides are complete - [ ] Ensure all automation scripts are documented - [ ] Check that all cross-references work #### Task 4: Usability Testing Test navigation from multiple starting points: - [ ] From index.md, can AI find any script? - [ ] From category file, can AI find specific scripts? - [ ] From execution guide, can AI understand how to execute? - [ ] From script context, can AI understand dependencies? Test with example queries: - [ ] "Find a media server script" → Should navigate to Media category - [ ] "How do I execute docker.sh non-interactively?" → Should find execution guide - [ ] "Create a new database service script" → Should find script creation guides - [ ] "What ports does jellyfin use?" → Should find jellyfin context file #### Task 5: Non-Interactive Mode Validation - [ ] Test default mode execution examples - [ ] Test advanced mode execution examples - [ ] Verify storage selection handling - [ ] Test prompt translation accuracy - [ ] Validate whiptail menu translations - [ ] Test error handling documentation #### Task 6: Automation Validation - [ ] Test `generate-context.sh` on sample scripts - [ ] Test `update-index.sh` with new scripts - [ ] Test `scan-new-scripts.sh` detection - [ ] Verify automation script documentation - [ ] Test automation script error handling #### Task 7: Quick Reference Cards Create quick reference cards for: - [ ] **Non-Interactive Execution** - 1-page guide with common patterns - [ ] **Script Creation** - 1-page checklist for new scripts - [ ] **Category Navigation** - 1-page category reference - [ ] **Common Issues** - 1-page troubleshooting guide - [ ] **Storage Selection** - 1-page storage handling guide #### Task 8: Cross-Reference Audit - [ ] Verify all links work (no broken links) - [ ] Check that all references have targets - [ ] Ensure circular references are intentional and helpful - [ ] Verify that scripts reference correct documentation - [ ] Check that categories reference correct scripts #### Task 9: Documentation Completeness Review each major documentation file: - [ ] `.llm-context/README.md` - Complete and accurate? - [ ] `.llm-context/index.md` - All navigation methods work? - [ ] Execution docs - All scenarios covered? - [ ] Script creation guides - All steps clear? - [ ] Category files - All information present? - [ ] Script context files - All details accurate? - [ ] Automation docs - All scripts documented? #### Task 10: Integration Review - [ ] AGENTS.md properly references context system? - [ ] README.md includes context system? - [ ] Templates updated correctly? - [ ] Contributing guidelines accurate? - [ ] CLI help text updated? - [ ] All cross-references work? ### Validation Checklist #### Accuracy - [ ] All script names match actual scripts - [ ] All ports are correct - [ ] All paths are accurate - [ ] All environment variables documented - [ ] All examples tested #### Consistency - [ ] Terminology consistent - [ ] Formatting consistent - [ ] Structure consistent - [ ] Navigation patterns consistent #### Completeness - [ ] All 408 scripts have context - [ ] All 26 categories populated - [ ] All guides complete - [ ] All automation scripts documented #### Usability - [ ] Easy to find information - [ ] Clear instructions - [ ] Working examples - [ ] Helpful cross-references #### Integration - [ ] All documentation linked - [ ] Templates updated - [ ] Contributing guidelines accurate - [ ] CLI help updated ### Expected Outcomes 1. **High-Quality Documentation** - Accurate, consistent, complete - Easy to navigate - Helpful examples 2. **Tested System** - Non-interactive mode validated - Navigation tested - Automation scripts tested 3. **Quick References** - 1-page reference cards - Quick start guides - Common patterns 4. **Final Integration** - All documentation linked - Templates updated - Contributing guidelines accurate ### Estimated Time 4-6 hours ### Dependencies - Phase 1-7 must be complete - All context files generated - All category files populated - All integration tasks complete ### Related Issues - #10521 - AI Context Enhancement - Overall Plan - #10522 - Phase 4: Category Files - #10523 - Phase 5: Script Context Files - #10524 - Phase 7: Integration & Updates ### Resources - All LLM Context System documentation - Automation scripts for testing - Quick reference card templates - Validation checklists ### Quick Reference Card Templates **Non-Interactive Execution Card** ```markdown # Non-Interactive Execution Quick Reference ## Default Mode (Simple) ```bash APP_NAME=example bash ct/example.sh ``` ## Advanced Mode (Custom Settings) ```bash APP_NAME=example \ APP_ADVANCED=true \ APP_CPU=4 \ APP_RAM=4096 \ APP_DISK=20 \ APP_STORAGE=local-lvm \ bash ct/example.sh ``` ## Storage Selection **Important**: Always ask user which storage drive when: - User requests advanced settings - Script requires storage selection - Multiple storage drives available ``` **Script Creation Card** ```markdown # Script Creation Quick Reference ## Checklist - [ ] Research service (use research-methodology.md) - [ ] Analyze dependencies (use dependency-analysis.md) - [ ] Plan resources (use resource-planning.md) - [ ] Select OS (use os-selection.md) - [ ] Choose pattern (use installation-patterns.md) - [ ] Use template (use template-guide.md) - [ ] Test and validate (use testing-validation.md) - [ ] Follow best practices (use best-practices.md) ``` --- **Labels**: `documentation`, `phase-8`, `review`, `qa`
OVERLORD commented 2026-02-05 04:23:11 +03:00
Author
Owner
Copy Link

@michelroegl-brunner commented on GitHub (Jan 4, 2026):

Why are you spamming with AI generated Issues? This could ve a discussion. Please stop this or we might consider other actions.

@michelroegl-brunner commented on GitHub (Jan 4, 2026): Why are you spamming with AI generated Issues? This could ve a discussion. Please stop this or we might consider other actions.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Branch/Tag Specified
Branches Tags
Labels
Clear labels
Implemented in VED waiting push to Main
breaking change
bug
bug
bugfix
deferred
delete script
dependencies
enhancement
external
feature
github
help wanted
in project pipeline
invalid
investigation
json
maintenance
needs triage
new script
new script
nice to have
not a script issue
not planned
organization
pull-request
Mirrored from GitHub Pull Request
 question
refactor
rename script
security
update script
website
wontdo
🛑 Failure to comply with the guidelines
No Label
Milestone
No items
No Milestone
Projects
Clear projects
No project
Assignees
Clear assignees
OVERLORD
No Assignees
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: starred/ProxmoxVE#2281
Delete Branch "%!s()"

Deleting a branch is permanent. Although the deleted branch may continue to exist for a short time before it actually gets removed, it CANNOT be undone in most cases. Continue?